इसकी शुरुआत
हुई थी “द नेशनल कौंग्रेस ब्रिगेड” के एक मेल से. कुछ ख़ास नहीं था बल्कि हिमाचल
में किसी कॉन्फ्रेंस के स्थगित होने की सुचना थी. देश में अभी-अभी हुए घटना से
आहात में, एक आम आदमी, ने अपना गुस्सा इस मेल पे निकालते हुए इसका जवाब दिया और ये
एक बहस बन गया. उसे आप लोगों के बीच प्रकाशित कर रहा हूँ... आप ही विचार कीजिये और
कहाँ-कहाँ मैं गलत हूँ मुझे अवगत कराइए... (मेल आईडी छिपा रहा हूँ... क्योंकि मैं किसी को भी आहात
नहीं करना चाहता...) पूरी बहस बिना किसी कान्त छांट के प्रकाशित कर रहा हूँ...
कौंग्रेस ब्रिगेड का पहला मेल : On Sat, Dec 22, 2012 at 9:23 PM, congress
brigade < > wrote:
THE NATIONAL CONGRESS
BRIGADE (इस मेल में एक अटैचमेंट
था जो मैं यहाँ प्रकाशित नहीं कर पा रहा क्योंकि मैंने उसे डीलीट कर दिया था.)
अभिषेक : Sent: Monday, 24 December
2012 10:18 AM
DO NOT SEND ME
THESE STUPID MAILS. DO FIRST FOR THE COUNTRY, THEN TELL ME ABOUT YOU.
WHERE IS YOUR LEADER AND YOUTH LEADER RAHUL GANDHI WHILE THE PEOPLE ARE ON THE
ROAD FOR THE JUSTICE.
रुकमनी
चंद्रन: On Tue, Dec 25, 2012
at 12:03 AM, Rukmini Chandran < > wrote:
Who are you? for which mail you are sending us this mail? Rahul Gandhi Better
work to do, their are so many people are appointed through many department to
work towards law and order and justice, what have you done to get thw justice
to the Girl as a citizen? Rahul ji cant work change the world with out the
people changing their thinking towards women
अभिषेक : Sent: Fri, 28 Dec 2012 09:47:36 +0530
I
am a common man... who wants the result... I know there are too many people to
work but they don't do with the honesty and responsibility. What Rahul Gandhi
is doing that is also we are looking. my only question is that why didn't he
come when people were on road... I am not expecting that he also join the crowd
but i want the answer... Why not the govt punished to those staff who was on
duty that night? there are many question what we want. This is the democracy
then why the people not answer us. I am not against with congress but to every
leader and every party. All are the same. if you can do then give our answer...
Can you answer us?
रुकमनी
चंद्रन: On Fri, Dec 28, 2012
at 11:47 AM, rukmini chandran < > wrote:
Hi, y do u think that he is not doing anything? Without the
central ministers approval do u think she can go to Singapor for better
treatment? If she is saved she can help the Govt to take better dicision in
punishing the culprit and also bring the crime under control, have pateince
अभिषेक : Sent: Fri, 28 Dec 2012 11:59:18 +0530
and do you think if public don't protest then govt send her
Singapore? So many girl raped earlier also in Not only in Delhi but whole
country, what happened with her? This time public protested then govt took the
action. also answer me why govt didn't take the action on those police officer
who were on duty that night. A bus "without permit" ran on the road
and none checked that and daily we common people scare to see them "kahin
police wale aake 50-100 rupaye jhaad na le, while we have the complete docs to
run our vehicle".
रुकमनी
चंद्रन: On Fri, Dec 28, 2012
at 2:41 PM, rukmini chandran < > wrote:
Hi,
Public never protested asking Govt to take her to Singapor! And in Delhi its
Congress Govt But in Karnataka its BJP Govt here also their is a Rape cases,
atleast in Delhi they have taken some step here Govt is not doing anything, so
Y targetting Rahul gandhi alone? Actually its in our hand, its like conducting
awareness program regarding Cancer/ Aids/ people know that Cigarate and paan
causes cancer still peopl smoke and eat paan! Same way every women knows that their
r bad eliments in the society, and they should should not trust unknown person
and ask for lift in odd hours, women also knows that they should not go to
isolated places alone still few women go knowingly or unknowingly, in this case
its that boyfriends mistake also is their he should have thought about his
girlfriends safty also before getting in to that empty bus with few men! The
girl also should have refused to get in to the bus so they could have avoided
the present situation
रुकमनी
चंद्रन: On Sat, Dec 29, 2012
at 1:06 AM, Rukmini Chandran < > wrote:
Y targetting
only Rahul Gandhi? did he tell the police officer not to be honest? does the
police officer comes under Rahul Gandhi directly? politicians comes and goes
but these officials are the one who works in the department till they retire,
the public should ask the police commissioner for his staffs negligence, if
department is not responding you should contact the home minister not Rahul
Gandhi, how Rahul Gandhi is connected to it? how Rahul Gandhi can give orders
to the Police officers and the staff?.
decissions are not made by any single person, before implimenting the
policy/rule/ their has to be discussions among the ministers and the concerned
committee which has members from diffarent party( in Center Govt is not
ruled by cong party alone it has ministers from other party also it has to take
approval from each members
rukmini
अभिषेक : Sent: Sat, 29 Dec 2012
10:14 AM
This is really funny... ya public never asked govt
to take her to Singapore but public is asking for the safe place, honest
officer, dark punishment and justice. I am repeating my question again, do
you think, if people didn't protest then govt sent her to Singapore? and
again I am saying I am not talking about the congress and BJP because I don't
believe on anyone. I am talking about the govt and I am targeting Mr. Rahul
just because he is the member of this Govt and he is so called Youth leader. I
am asking that why he is not there with the youth while he is a youth leader.
Answer for Your other unnecessary question, people
know that the Cigarette and Paan caused Cancer and still people smoke and
eat paan. Just tell me one thing. in the family of five any one got bad
habbits, like alcohal, smoke and other then what father do? He stopped all
these, he pursuade to his son/daughter, he punished for that. As per the same
Govt is like the father of this family, then why Paan and Cigarette and alcohal
is selling in this market?
by the way I don't want the answer for that
otherwise we will lose our main path. i agree with you that woman must not
trust on anyone but this is not the humanity. we are a social animal and we all
need time to time to others. My main question is that why that bus was
running on the road while it had not the permit?
And the last one, as all politician don't compare
yourself with others. I am talking about you. what the bjp is doing that is the
another matter, You just talk about you not for others. Your example just feel
me that i got the right also to murder, rape, corruption because other does it
too.
अभिषेक : Sent: Sat, 29 Dec 2012
10:28 AM
किसने कह दिया की मैं सिर्फ राहुल गांधी को टार्गेट
कर रहा हूँ... राहुल गांधी ब्रिगेड से आपका मेल आया इसलिए ये सवाल खड़ा किया. ये भी
सच है की उन्होंने पुलिस को बेईमान होने के लिए नहीं कहा पर जो बेईमान हो गए उनके
खिलाफ भी तो कुछ नहीं किया. पुलिस उनके अन्दर नहीं है, पर उन्ही के
पार्टी की सरकार के अन्दर है. राजनीतिग्य आते है और चले जाते है पर हमने उन्हें
इसलिए चुना है ताकि वो हमारी देश की व्यवस्था पर ध्यान रख सके. पूल्स कमिश्नर से
सीधी जवाब-देहि हमारी नहीं बनती, हमारा सवाल हमारे प्रतिनिधि से है... और जिस होम मिनिस्टर
के पास जाने का आप सुझाव दे रहे है वो राहुल की पार्टी के सदस्य है. और मेरा सवाल
उनसे इसलिए है की इस देश का नागरिक होने के नाते मैं ये अधिकार रखता हूँ की मैं
अपने प्रतिनिधि से सवाल पूछ सकूँ. राहुल गांधी खुद को युवा प्रतिनिधि कहते है और
मैं एक युवा हूँ... तो मैं कहाँ जाऊं... गलती किसी ने भी की हो क्या मदद के लिए
अपने प्रतिनिधि के पास नहीं आ सकता? अगर लोकतंत्र में ऐसा होता है की हमारे द्वारा चुने
गए प्रतिनिधि हमारे सवालों का जवाब नहीं देना चाहते तो मैं चाहता हूँ इस देश में
किसी हिटलर या सद्दाम की सरकार हो...
इस
मेल के बाद अभी जवाब मिला नहीं है... जवाब मिलते ही पोस्ट करूँगा...